View Full Submission View Parent Comment
8:21 PM, Wednesday March 9th 2022

Starting with your organic forms with contour curves, these are progressing fairly well. The sausage forms themselves are fairly close to the characteristics of simple sausages, although there are definitely some cases where you end up drifting farther away from those specific characteristics. I suspect that cases like this one (where one end is way bigger than the other), and this one where the bend is really dramatic occur because you've drawn your big masses, and now you're left trying to fill in the empty spaces in order to ensure a "filled" page. It's possible that in these smaller spaces you're more likely to draw from your elbow instead of your shoulder - so make sure that when you're drawing these smaller ones, that you're still thinking about everything you need to be prioritizing.

Additionally, your contour curves are coming along as well, although they are a little more visibly hesitant/stiff than the sausage marks. This again may be due to drawing from your elbow instead of the shoulder, though I can't really say - you could just be more hesitant. The solution for that is the same as usual - make sure you're using the ghosting method (which focuses on that execution phase being as confident as possible, regardless of any fears or worries you may have - which is very much a mind-over-matter thing), and of course being sure to draw with your whole arm from the shoulder, which functions like a stabilizer in digital software, making it impossible for you to make sudden or jerky movements.

Continuing onto your sausage chains, the first thing I noticed was that you very frequently create shorter sausages with really dramatic bends in them. Sometimes you're able to do this while sticking fairly close to the characteristics of simple sausages, but in general it does tend to result in you deviating further from those characteristics, with more pinching through the midsection. As I've marked out here, try to avoid the sort of "bean" shape where they're shorter and more dramatically curved through their midsections - insect and animal legs in general tend to be much longer and smoother. They do have some slight curving to them, but it's a much gentler curve, like a subtle sense of motion back and forth, rather than quicker zigzagging.

I suspect this is one of the bigger issues that you're running into when drawing your insects. You tend to draw your sausages shorter and with sharper curves, and when the insects' legs require longer sausages, you often end up drawing the whole sausage bigger (like scaling it up), resulting in a much thicker sausage than is required. So for example, in this construction I've drawn on top with much more reasonably sized sausages - note how they're all slender, and there isn't much in the way of curve to them. There's a little bit of arcing, but it's subtle and gentle, just like smoothly running water.

Now, to that point, I did notice that if we look at your pages of sausages, and then the pages of smaller sausages, they're not actually all that different in size (as shown here. As smaller sausages are definitely something you're struggling with, you will likely find yourself avoiding it - it is for this reason that you'll need to pay closer attention to exactly what it is you're doing, and more directly enforce your own will over the actions you take.

Before we continue from here, I want you to try and work on those smaller sausages. I'll assign some more revisions below.

Next Steps:

Please submit:

  • 3 pages of sausage chains that specifically focus on being narrower/skinnier, and longer, with far less in terms of that sharp/tight curving/bending.

  • 3 more insect constructions, keeping an eye on the size/thickness of your sausage structures.

When finished, reply to this critique with your revisions.
6:01 PM, Sunday March 13th 2022

https://imgur.com/a/ZH3Dte2

Working on improvment slowly.

5:46 PM, Monday March 14th 2022

3 pages of sausage chains that specifically focus on being narrower/skinnier, and longer, with far less in terms of that sharp/tight curving/bending.

So here you've had some progress, as well as some areas that weren't really addressed as much as I'd have liked.

In terms of the progress, I think the sausage shapes themselves (in terms of being smoother, less sharply curved, etc.) are coming along much better. One small change I'd offer in that area is, as shown here, reverse the curvature of the sausages from one to the next, as this is more similar to what you'd actually see in a leg structure. This allows the gestural flow to pass more smoothly back and forth, whereas having all of the sausages curved in the same direction tends to hinder that sense of fluidity.

There are however a couple issues that do stand out to me:

  • While most of this page is quite good (aside from this one as well as the lower two where things definitely get sloppier), your next two pages of sausage chains progressively seem to be a bit more rushed, especially when placing the contour lines themselves. This seems like a pretty standard case of getting tired and losing focus. To put it simply, earlier in the set we see more cases like this (contour line placed more carefully right at the joint between the sausages), and later in the set we see more cases like this (contour lines placed more haphazardly).

  • Similarly there's a tendency to get sloppy with the shape of your sausages - but this is more towards the bottom of each page, with the top of the page being better. For example, on this final page the top is still pretty decent, but the bottom is running into a lot of issues.

3 more insect constructions, keeping an eye on the size/thickness of your sausage structures.

I imagine this is largely because the practice still involved drawing sausages at a fairly large scale (compared to what we end up using in our actual insect constructions), even though you did get quite a bit better at avoiding those more dramatic curves in your sausages, we still see a ton of them in your insect constructions. While I think targeting the basic sausage chains themselves has been beneficial and is making progress in a number of areas, it's time to target these issues a little more directly.

So, here's what we're going to do. You're going to start by grabbing a ton of insect references - you can certainly reuse ones you've used before. Then, digitally, I want you to trace sausages right onto the photos, on top of where their legs are. So for example, like this (you'll probably also want to lower the opacity of the reference image as I did there). Note that I'm still just drawing simple sausage forms even when the legs have way bigger chunks to them. Don't worry about the areas that get big for now, just focus on sticking to the characteristics of simple sausages as much as you can.

Once you've done this on a bunch of reference images (hopefully noting that most of them do not have really dramatic curves to them), then I want you to copy all of those sausage structures you'd already traced onto a page with your pen. So what we should have in the end is a bunch of sausage chains, but arranged as per the reference image they were pulled from. We won't be creating them from our imagination this time around.

I'm only going to ask for one page of these, but I specifically want you to draw each sausage structure at the size it'd be if you were drawing the whole insect. Meaning, don't draw the chains really big, I want you to get more practice drawing them at the correct scale. And of course, fill the page as much as you can once again.

Next Steps:

Please submit 1 page of sausage chains from reference as described above, along with all of the reference images you traced sausage chains on top of.

It would also help if on each reference image you labeled the legs with letters (A, B, C, D, etc.) and then marked the corresponding legs on your page with the same letters so I can check the corresponding legs in your references.

When finished, reply to this critique with your revisions.
1:44 AM, Thursday March 17th 2022
edited at 1:46 AM, Mar 17th 2022
edited at 1:46 AM, Mar 17th 2022
View more comments in this thread
1:46 AM, Thursday March 17th 2022

https://imgur.com/a/tVBL4Xl Sasauge chains

https://imgur.com/a/tVBL4Xl Refrences used Numbered

The recommendation below is an advertisement. Most of the links here are part of Amazon's affiliate program (unless otherwise stated), which helps support this website. It's also more than that - it's a hand-picked recommendation of something I've used myself. If you're interested, here is a full list.
Color and Light by James Gurney

Color and Light by James Gurney

Some of you may remember James Gurney's breathtaking work in the Dinotopia series. This is easily my favourite book on the topic of colour and light, and comes highly recommended by any artist worth their salt. While it speaks from the perspective of a traditional painter, the information in this book is invaluable for work in any medium.

This website uses cookies. You can read more about what we do with them, read our privacy policy.