0 users agree
11:14 PM, Friday February 7th 2020

Alrighty! Starting with your organic forms with contour curves, you're definitely moving in the direction of sticking with simple sausage forms but yours still do have a tendency to widen through their midsection. Keep working on getting them to maintain equally sized, spherical ends connected by a tube of consistent width.

I'm also noticing that the degree of your contour curves appears to remain pretty consistent (rather than widening/narrowing as we move along the length of the form). I do believe you understand the concept of how the degree of the contour line reflects the orientation of that circular cross-section relative to the orientation of the viewer, but that you likely just weren't focusing on it here.

Moving onto your insect constructions, I think these redline notes I did over your grasshopper drawing capture a lot of major issues that need to be addressed:

  • Remember that we are not drawing a bunch of lines on a page - at least, that's not how you should be thinking about this. We are constructing solid forms in a 3D world. This means that every form we draw must be complete and enclosed.

  • Draw through your forms, as though you have x-ray vision. The back leg there should not have been left half-drawn, as this simply makes us treat it as though we're drawing lines, or flat shapes. These drawings are all just exercises in spatial reasoning - to properly understand how each form exists in space, and how they relate to one another, we need to draw each one in its entirety.

  • For your head construction, you attempted to capture too much all at once. Instead, start with a simple form and build your way up, adding more simple forms as you go, always keeping in mind how they all relate to one another in space. You can see the little demo I drew there about how I start with a sphere. It's not really meant to be a detailed demonstration, but you can see a similar concept covered in this demonstration on how to build up a claw.

  • You're not employing the sausage technique. when constructing your legs. This method is extremely important, as it allows us to capture our creatures' legs (be they insects, animals, or whatever else) in a way that appears solid and tangible, while remaining gestural. The key however is in actually using simple sausage forms (equally sized spheres connected by tubes of consistent width, which admittedly can be somewhat difficult to draw at a small scale), having them intersect properly, and reinforcing the joint between them with a single contour line.

On the topic of the sausage method, I can see that you tried to employ it partially in some places, like this bee, but we can see that you're only partially sticking to simple sausage forms. It is good that you did add additional masses after the fact to some parts in order to bulk them out, though more recently I've found that the approach detailed here is more effective.

The whole concept of focusing on simple forms is really important, because every time we introduce more complexity to a form, it becomes harder to make it appear solid and three dimensional. So when we're looking at things like this praying mantis, the long, narrow thorax is far more complex than it needs to be, in how it gets pinched through its midsection and swells out towards the ends. Maintaining a consistent width (just like in the sausages) helps maintain this simplicity and the illusion that it's a real, solid form.

Now, I think I've covered a lot of points here, and it'll take some time to properly absorb it all. Once you've been able to properly take it all in, there's some additional drawings I'd like to see before I can let you move on.

Next Steps:

I'd like to see 6 more insect drawings. Focus on the drawing approach I demonstrate in that claw demo - every mark is drawn confidently, focusing on achieving smooth, consistent strokes (that don't wobble which can add unintentional complexity), and being very direct about every form you're adding to the construction.

When finished, reply to this critique with your revisions.
12:02 AM, Saturday February 8th 2020

Hi, thanks for the feedback. Is it ok if I draw the same insect species I drew in the original submission? Or do I have to find new insect species?

3:58 AM, Saturday February 8th 2020

That is absolutely fine.

10:14 PM, Monday February 10th 2020

https://imgur.com/gallery/z1DvtZq

So this is my revision. I have to admit I didn't know how to utilize the method you referenced in your critique regarding the bee's legs so I used the same old method. I hope thats ok.

9:46 PM, Tuesday February 11th 2020

These are certainly an improvement, although there's still an issue that I mentioned earlier that you've not corrected. In my previous critique, I mentioned:

The key however is in actually using simple sausage forms (equally sized spheres connected by tubes of consistent width, which admittedly can be somewhat difficult to draw at a small scale), having them intersect properly, and reinforcing the joint between them with a single contour line.

You're doing a much better job of the first of these - using simple sausage forms for the segments - and your segments overlap fairly well. What you're missing however is the last point. You're not reinforcing the intersections between the sausage forms with a contour line, as demonstrated in the middle of this diagram. Without this, there is no real illusion that the legs are three dimensional.

I have to admit I didn't know how to utilize the method you referenced in your critique regarding the bee's legs so I used the same old method. I hope thats ok.

If you struggle to understand how to apply a concept, the answer to that problem is not to fall back to an earlier approach. It is to give it a shot anyway, end up with a result that doesn't come out well, and get feedback on that attempt. Without seeing you trying to apply the concept, there's not much I can do to actually see where you're going wrong.

While you have room for improvement, I am going to mark this lesson as complete. Reason being, both of these concepts are a major part of lesson 5 - both the use of the sausage technique to construct underlying structures for your animals' legs, and the use of additional masses that wrap around the existing structure to bulk out parts of your construction. You will have plenty of opportunities to apply the approach I demonstrated previously, and I expect you to approach them in that way even if it comes out badly.

Remember that the goal is not a pretty drawing - if we ultimately gain more from drawing something badly (be it through what we learn by doing it, or by having something that allows someone else to explain the issues later on), then a crappy drawing is vastly more useful.

Next Steps:

Move onto lesson 5.

This critique marks this lesson as complete.
The recommendation below is an advertisement. Most of the links here are part of Amazon's affiliate program (unless otherwise stated), which helps support this website. It's also more than that - it's a hand-picked recommendation of something I've used myself. If you're interested, here is a full list.
Color and Light by James Gurney

Color and Light by James Gurney

Some of you may remember James Gurney's breathtaking work in the Dinotopia series. This is easily my favourite book on the topic of colour and light, and comes highly recommended by any artist worth their salt. While it speaks from the perspective of a traditional painter, the information in this book is invaluable for work in any medium.

This website uses cookies. You can read more about what we do with them, read our privacy policy.