View Full Submission View Parent Comment
0 users agree
9:00 PM, Saturday May 2nd 2020

So your work overall shows a great deal of promise and existing skill, but also shows that you've made a significant break from the principles covered in previous lessons, specifically in regards to your actual linework. In terms of your spatial reasoning skills, you've shown considerable improvement over your last lesson, but overall it becomes considerably more difficult to parse the specifics when your linework consists largely of broken and dashed lines.

It's very clear that your focus here was primarily on ending up with a pretty drawing at the end, rather than following the methodologies set out by the course and shown in the many demonstrations in this lesson. As you can see in each of these, I approach each and every mark in these drawings with confidence - each form is fully enclosed in order to encourage the illusion of solidity, and when I approach construction I am not at all concerned with how those marks will impede my ability to add detail afterwards. This is for a very simple reason: every single drawing in this course is an exercise. The focus is not on the end result, but rather on the process we employ. We are not learning to draw pretty things, we are learning how to convey forms such that they feel solid and three dimensional and solid.

You are clearly capable of this, but you need to be willing and able to follow the instructions exactly as they're written, not to modify the requirements to better suit a secondary goal you may have for yourself. So to that point, you are going to be drawing a few more of these so I can assess them as the exercise they're intended to be, and give you a more meaningful critique.

Now, to your question about aquatic animals - or more specifically, plenty of animals that don't necessarily follow this specific recipe, it comes around again to the lessons being about learning how to understand the spatial relationships between forms, and to be able to manipulate and combine them in various ways to create more complex objects. The specific recipe given with a head/chest/pelvis isn't going to suit every kind of creature, but working through them as exercises does ultimately help train our capacity to move beyond constructional drawing itself to understand how everything is three dimensional and how these forms fit together. In some of the newer content covered in Lesson 0 - specifically the three first videos (here's the first one) - I actually have a drawing in the background while I talk that shows absolutely no construction whatsoever, but does demonstrate an understanding of how everything I'm drawing exists in 3D space, rather than on a flat canvas.

There will be plenty of things you will want to draw that don't fit a particular mould, but they will all share this same basic foundation - that they exist in 3D space, not on a flat page. I think you've made considerable progress to grasping this on the intuitive level it is intended to, and that is exactly why you ended up going astray when tackling this lesson. Something appears to have clicked, and the drawings you produced ended up being quite nice, all this considered. You are indeed showing an understanding of the things you draw as existing in 3D space.

To that point, when looking at a jellyfish or an octopus, focus on the major forms you see. Some forms - like the bulb of a jellyfish - will have a particular focus on appearing more solid, so you focus on establishing that solidity. The tendrills in the otherhand will have more flow and fluidity to them. They're gestural to the extreme - where an insect or animal's legs, or even the stem of a plant uses certain techniques (branches, sausages) to capture its solidity and its fluidity, here the solidity is no longer much of a concern. With an octopus on the other hand, I would actually create more of a chain of boxes to capture the major planes of a tentacle structure - think something like this advanced version of the box challenge exercise.

Anyway, as I said, I'm going to be assigning a few additional pages below for you to demonstrate that you can apply the principles of drawing your lines confidently, enclosing solid forms without broken lines, and overall focus on these drawings as exercises rather than striving to do what you can to make the drawings come out prettily in the end.

Next Steps:

I'd like to see 3 additional animal drawings of your choice. Focus on how I draw in my demonstrations - especially the informal ones at the end of the lesson. My lines are all complete and unbroken, with no attempt at hiding them. My focus is only ever on what I'm doing at that moment, whether it's constructing a solid form or establishing how different forms relate to one another.

When finished, reply to this critique with your revisions.
4:48 AM, Monday May 4th 2020

Thank you for noticing my bad habits about the lines... I need to work on getting rid of them soon...

Here are the pages you requested! https://imgur.com/a/MjAWZLz

ever since i started Lesson 5 i was very keen on not adding any details in my animal drawings since you did tell me on Lesson 4 critiq to not aim for pretty drawing... i actually thought this was the case so far but i guess i've been doing it unconsciously .. if my last pages do look appealing then definitely know it was not my intention...

Thanks again and stay safe!

8:06 PM, Monday May 4th 2020

So these are definitely a big improvement, and have made it considerably easier to point out your primary issues. Instead of writing out my critique here, I ended up doing most of it directly on your work with little examples and visual explanations to help you understand them better. You'll find it here.

Main points:

  1. When constructing your animals' muzzles, you seem to create a larger form, then create another form whose relationship with the larger container are fairly loosely defined. Wherever possible, try and work additively - that is, adding forms on top of one another instead of cutting back into them. When you do have to add subtractively, it focuses on having strongly defined relationships between all the resulting forms. You can see a more specific breakdown of how I tackle head construction here. There is also a moose head construction above it.

  2. You are overdoing your contour lines. It's not uncommon for students to just pile them on because they they're a technique they know how to use. You have to be thinking about what you're attempting to accomplish with each mark you put down however, and what that mark is going to contribute to the drawing. Applying techniques blindly will often causes us to add lines that serve no real purpose of their own.

  3. Constructional drawing is all about moving from a simple structure and using that as a scaffolding for more complex structures that are built off of it. If you jump too complex too soon, without adequate structure to support it, then your construction will fall flat.

  4. You still have a tendency to think more in terms of drawing lines on a page. Every single element you add to your drawing needs to be understood as an independent three dimensional form. Lines do not exist on their own, and so if those silhouettes are broken, the forms they're meant to define will not appear solid, and the construction upon which they're built will fall apart. You've definitely gotten better at drawing more purposefully, but you're still being quite timid in a number of areas, and need to work on that a fair bit.

Before I mark this lesson as complete, I'm going to ask you to do 4 more drawings applying the points I've raised here. I want you to do no more than one of these in a given day - this is to ensure that you don't attempt to get everything done at once. This also means I will expect you to submit no sooner than 4 days from now.

For these drawings, I've got two main restrictions:

  • You will not be allowed to use any contour lines that sit on the surface of a single form. Contour lines that define the relationship between two separate forms are allowed (like the joint contour lines in the sauage technique).

  • You will not be allowed to get into any texture or detail. Take constructed forms as far as they can go.

Next Steps:

The 4 additional animal drawings, as instructed above.

When finished, reply to this critique with your revisions.
3:16 PM, Sunday May 10th 2020
edited at 7:04 PM, May 10th 2020

here is the pages you requested https://imgur.com/a/DLEOBHH

you may have been expecting them 2 days earlier but i just had to take a break from drawing animals as i got tired of them and wanted to focus more on stuff that i enjoy like urban sketching...

I haven't neglected my daily warm ups so i hope it's fine

edited at 7:04 PM, May 10th 2020
View more comments in this thread
The recommendation below is an advertisement. Most of the links here are part of Amazon's affiliate program (unless otherwise stated), which helps support this website. It's also more than that - it's a hand-picked recommendation of something I've used myself. If you're interested, here is a full list.
Faber Castell PITT Artist Pens

Faber Castell PITT Artist Pens

Like the Staedtlers, these also come in a set of multiple weights - the ones we use are F. One useful thing in these sets however (if you can't find the pens individually) is that some of the sets come with a brush pen (the B size). These can be helpful in filling out big black areas.

Still, I'd recommend buying these in person if you can, at a proper art supply store. They'll generally let you buy them individually, and also test them out beforehand to weed out any duds.

This website uses cookies. You can read more about what we do with them, read our privacy policy.