View Full Submission View Parent Comment
3:25 AM, Tuesday April 27th 2021

So there's definitely improvement here, and I can see an overall developing grasp of how these forms all fit together like pieces of a puzzle to create larger, more solid constructions. There are some things I want you to keep an eye on however:

  • Don't be too excessive on those contour lines. You need to think about where the contour lines are going to have the most impact, and actually consider whether adding another will help. The rat drawing, for instance, has a ton of contour lines on its length, but they're not really helping. Instead, one defining the relationship between it and the rat's torso would have been far more valuable - and frankly would have been all you needed.

  • Draw through your ellipses. Not a big point to make, but a basic rule in this course that should be adhered to whenever freehanding any ellipses

  • Draw each and every form in its entirety, without exception. You've done this a fair bit, but there are cases where you draw a shape that just ends suddenly where it's overlapped by something else. We have to draw each and every form in its entirety, defining that entire silhouette so we can understand how they all exist in 3D space individually, and then how they relate to one another. That's a pretty big issue in these drawings as a whole - they have a tendency to feel much more like you're just drawing individual lines, rather than adding whole forms, one at a time, to build up to the resulting structure.

  • You don't appear to be adding a contour line at the joint between your sausage forms, as shown in the middle of the sausage method diagram. This comes back to the idea of defining the relationships between our forms, as they exist in 3D space.

  • For the head construction, you're moving in the right direction, but try to stick to the pentagon-shaped eye sockets, with the point facing downwards, as shown in the demo. For some reason, that shape just works better, creating a nice wedge for the muzzle to fit into, and a flat table for the brow ridge to rest upon.

  • Keep working on drawing your eyes. Instead of drawing the eyelids as just lines, try to add them as their own complete additional masses, wrapping them around the ball form of the eyeball.

I've outlined a number of things for you to work on. You are headed in the right direction, and if you're able to resolve these issues, you should be well on your way.

I'm going to assign some revisions below, but I want to impose one additional restriction on them: you may not add any contour lines that sit along the surface of a single form. You can still use contour lines to define the joint/relationship between different forms, but the kind that you used on the rat's tail should be left out of your revisions.

Next Steps:

Please submit 2 additional pages of animal constructions.

When finished, reply to this critique with your revisions.
6:11 PM, Thursday April 29th 2021

Return of the Revisions,

Here are my thoughts when I was working on these. Maybe it can help with pinpointing issues with my approach:

Cat:

  • Used the branch method to build the tail

  • I drew the back leg even if the reference didn't show it. But didn't do the same thing for the front leg because it was too much going on in that area

  • The contour lines on the joints of the ket leg: I don't think it was supposed to go through the whole joint shape, just the initial sausage.

Owl:

  • Not sure if I'm adding masses correctly to the neck. This applies to all the animals

General

  • To me it seems like I've drawn every from in it's entirety. However, I might be misunderstanding. Could you point out a few examples with screenshots if I'm still not getting this xD?

Many thanks!

9:20 PM, Thursday April 29th 2021

Here are some notes. You're really not particularly far off from doing a fairly good job, but there are definitely still things that stand out as problems. I've noted them out there, and I'll list them below as well.

  • You asked about where you're not drawing forms in their entirety. If you take a look at the two areas I circled at the koala's neck, these are places where the outline of these additional masses just stop where they hit another form. This is what I'm talking about - you should be drawing each form entirely, adding a new fully enclosed silhouette to the drawing. Leaving them open like that causes us to understand it as a 2D shape rather than a 3D form.

  • The masses you're building up along the pig's back are coming along fairly well, though the one that comes up along its neck also shares the same problem - you left it open ended. Also, note how I drew the masses on top - every corner I define in that silhouette is in response to what it's pressing against. Here you'll see that I've got a little arrow pointing at a pretty distinct corner that doesn't actually exist in response to anything in particular. All in all you're making a lot of progress with these additional masses, but there are things you need to keep thinking about.

  • Your sausage forms for the legs are kind of hit and miss, for two reasons. Firstly, some of them lean more towards being ellipses - getting wider through their midsections, and not having entirely circular ends. This concept of the "characteristics of simple sausages" as demonstrated on the sausage method diagram is incredibly important. It's not always easy to nail, but I think this is something you do need to work on. Having those forms get wider through their midsection basically makes them stiff, and results in a rigid leg construction with no real fluidity/gesture to it. Conversely, when we're able to keep the width of those sausage segments consistent, we get more of a sort of "flexible tube" which can convey a greater sense of gesture.

  • As a side note, it doesn't look like you're really drawing through the majority of your ellipses as you ought to be, two full times, before lifting your pen.

  • For your eyelids, I've got a little demonstration there of what I mean by constructing them as a complete form/mass. Think about taking a piece of clay or putty and actually covering the eyeball with it. That's effectively what an eyelid is. It's not just creating an edge to create the iconic "eye" shape - it's about the whole piece that goes all the way up.

  • For the feet, don't work with arbitrary blobs. Use corners in those silhouettes to differentiate the different planes of that structure.

So, that's a number of things for you to work on. Try another 2 pages of animal constructions.

Next Steps:

Another 2 pages of animal constructions.

When finished, reply to this critique with your revisions.
7:16 PM, Monday May 3rd 2021

Hello,

I'm back with more revisions

View more comments in this thread
The recommendation below is an advertisement. Most of the links here are part of Amazon's affiliate program (unless otherwise stated), which helps support this website. It's also more than that - it's a hand-picked recommendation of something I've used myself. If you're interested, here is a full list.
Pentel Pocket Brush Pen

Pentel Pocket Brush Pen

This is a remarkable little pen. Technically speaking, any brush pen of reasonable quality will do, but I'm especially fond of this one. It's incredibly difficult to draw with (especially at first) due to how much your stroke varies based on how much pressure you apply, and how you use it - but at the same time despite this frustration, it's also incredibly fun.

Moreover, due to the challenge of its use, it teaches you a lot about the nuances of one's stroke. These are the kinds of skills that one can carry over to standard felt tip pens, as well as to digital media. Really great for doodling and just enjoying yourself.

This website uses cookies. You can read more about what we do with them, read our privacy policy.