View Full Submission View Parent Comment
8:10 PM, Friday May 24th 2024

Thanks for the critique. No worries here on the wait time. I'm glad you mentioned the lego texture because that one in particular threw me for a loop. I had tried to have my shadows appear to cast onto other lego bricks but i found that to be very difficult to do without any explicit form to lay the cast shadow on top of. To avoid turning the drawing into form shading do you think for this example it would be more effective to have the legos appear to cast their shadows on a flat surface rather than other legos? I think the diagram with the candle wax you sent me seems to possibly be doing that but the topography is still relatively pretty flat so I'm not too sure.

7:37 PM, Monday May 27th 2024

The thing to keep in mind most of all is that it's an exercise. Exercises are where we make mistakes, where we struggle against things at the edge of our ability or beyond it, and where we grow by way of that struggle. So the fact that it's so challenging isn't something we necessary should be avoiding.

But it is very challenging, because of how compared to other textures that are much more regular (like the wax example) don't end up with large chunks of surfaces that are at dramatically different angles than if we were just dealing with a simple flat one. Yeah, there's curvature and deformation, but compared to having a scattering of box forms that can be set at any old angle, it's day and night.

The thing to avoid in terms of what results in form shading is that you have to remember that every shadow you add is a new shape. It can be tempting to fill in existing shapes (like the side planes of your lego blocks), but that is precisely what form shading is - the entirety of a surface getting darker or lighter based on its relationship with the light source.

A cast shadow will fall upon one of these surfaces, but it more often than not is only going to cover part of it - and even if the whole thing gets engulfed, the process of first designing that shadow shape by outlining it will help you avoid situations where you just automatically fill in those existing planes.

4:38 PM, Wednesday May 29th 2024

Understood. Thanks for the clarification.

The recommendation below is an advertisement. Most of the links here are part of Amazon's affiliate program (unless otherwise stated), which helps support this website. It's also more than that - it's a hand-picked recommendation of something we've used ourselves, or know to be of impeccable quality. If you're interested, here is a full list.
Steven Zapata's Secrets of Shading

Steven Zapata's Secrets of Shading

Some of you will have noticed that Drawabox doesn't teach shading at all. Rather, we focus on the understanding of the spatial relationships between the form we're drawing, which feeds into how one might go about applying shading. When it comes time to learn about shading though, you're going to want to learn it from Steven Zapata, hands down.

Take a look at his portfolio, and you'll immediately see why.

This website uses cookies. You can read more about what we do with them, read our privacy policy.