Hello, I will be critiquing your work

Lines

  • starting with your superimposed lines these are off to a good start. You are clearly keeping a defined starting point. I think you could benifit from spending a little more time ghosting and remember to prioritize flow over accuracy.

  • the initial ghosting lines are a little wobbly but moving down they are looking confident.

  • looks like you haven't uploaded ghosted planes without ellipses. You were supposed to upload 2 pages of ghosted planes and 2 pages of ellipses in planes seperately. I am going to let you off this time but be careful while uploading homework in the future. overall the planes with the ellipses have turned out good.

Ellipses

  • the ellipses in the table are drawn 2-3 times but some of them are looking a little wobbly. This is probably happening because you are more concerned with accuracy but always prioritize flow over accuracy. Again with your ellipses try spending a little more time ghosting.

In the funnel exercise most of the ellipses are aligned with the minor axis but you should try varying the degree of your ellipses.

Ellipses in the table are turning out good. some of them are coming out of the boundry of planes but this should improve with practice.

Boxes

  • the plotted perspective looks great, nothing to mention here.

-in the rough perspective you have drawn more than one line for the edges of some boxes but you should always avoid this. Also the estimations for vanishing point is a bit off but this should also improve with practice.

-you rotated boxes are looking good and I can see that you have commited to the linework here a lot better.

  • lastly in organic perspective the boxes are turning out good and there are some overshooting lines but that should also improve with practice.

Overall the exercises of this lesson are done quite neatly.

Always use this lesson in your warmup routine.