Lesson 5: Applying Construction to Animals

3:34 PM, Wednesday August 26th 2020

DAB-Lesson5-Cheerful - Album on Imgur

Imgur: https://imgur.com/gallery/voHCPng

Discover the magic of the internet at Imgur, a community powered enterta...

reference images: https://imgur.com/gallery/q3xPM4R

Would also particularly like critique on my alligator head as I struggled a ton with it.

0 users agree
1:34 AM, Friday August 28th 2020

Starting with your organic intersections, these are looking great. You're doing a good job of piling them up in a way that feels stable and believable, and the forms themselves feel solid and three dimensional.

Moving onto your animal constructions, there's a lot of good here, but there are also a number of issues I want to draw your attention to. I picked on your hyena construction specifically, as it was fairly well done, but could be used to demonstrate the points I want to emphasize to you. I've added notes directly on the drawing here, but I'll address the major ones below:

  • Firstly, for your additional masses, you tend to bury them in contour lines, and those contour lines generally don't really contribute much of anything to those forms. If you look at how I drew my own additional masses in their place in red, you'll notice that I didn't actually add any contour lines on top of them, because they weren't actually needed. This is because when drawing them I focused entirely on establishing a relationship between each form and the structure that lay beneath it. In creating this relationship, I was able to believably make that form feel as though it exists in 3D space. By focusing on how that form is wrapping around the existing structure, we bind it more tightly to the construction, rather than giving the impression that it's just a flat shape, or perhaps a 3D form that is resting gently on top (that could ostensibly fall off at any point).

  • The thing about contour lines is that they come in different varieties. At its core, a contour line is just the idea of describing how one surface deforms through space by placing another element - be it a line, or in this case a whole other form - such that it runs along that surface. A contour line that sits only on a single surface only goes as far as to make that one form feel solid on its own, in isolation. This can be useful in some cases, but it also suffers from diminishing returns. The first may contribute a fair bit in this regard, but the second less so, and the third and fourth may have no impact at all. Rather than burying your forms with many contour lines, focus on making sure that the contour line you choose to add is executed as well as possible - and before you even do that, look for opportunities in how the form itself is drawn to establish its relationship with the forms around it.

  • As there are different kinds of contour lines, there's one that you were missing entirely in your use of the sausage method. As explained in the middle of this diagram, you are to place a single contour line at the joint between each pair of sausages, to help reinforce their relationship with one another. This kind of contour line - the one that creates the relationship between forms - is far more effective than the kind that sits on a single form, as it creates a connection that states if one of these forms is 3D, then so too must the other one be 3D.

  • Lastly - and I actually mentioned this at the end of my lesson 4 critique - as there will be many situations where you will want to be able to take that simple sausage structure further to add bulk wherever it's required, you must do this through the addition of more forms, NOT by simply modifying the silhouette of the forms you've already drawn. An object's silhouette is like the footprint of an animal. In finding a footprint, you may be able to identify all kinds of things about that animal without ever having seen the animal itself - how big it is, what kind of animal it might be, etc. But the footprint itself is not the animal, and if you change that footprint, you're not changing the animal that left it. You're just making the footprint a lot less useful. In this sense, modifying the silhouette of a form you've already drawn only breaks the illusion that we're looking at something real and 3D, and turns it into nothing more than a flat drawing. If you want to add bulk to the legs, you need to do so by wrapping further forms around it, as shown in the little example I drew on your page, as well as here.

Moving onto the alligator on which you requested some feedback, an important thing to point out is that the point of this lesson isn't to teach you how to draw all animals - at least, not exactly. This lesson is no different from the last two - it's about developing your spatial reasoning skills by looking at how to combine forms in particular ways, using construction (with specific subject matter in each lesson) as an exercise to develop that skill. You aren't actually tied down to particular approaches or recipes, but for the time being, the cranium-ribcage-pelvis model gives you something to hold onto while you wade out into these concepts. That also doesn't mean it's the best way to approach every animal.

I'm assuming you're working from this reference image, based on the pose. It's definitely a challenging one, specifically because of how far the structure of the gator differs from the other kinds of animals we've tackled. The same principles still apply - that is to say we can still break it down into a series of simple forms - but in this case we might instead want to start out with more box forms, in order to break it down into its major planes.

That said, there are some more immediate issues with your approach. First of all, if I'm correct about the reference image used, the camera angle is pretty sharply different - the reference is angled lower, whereas your drawing is more of a top-down view. There are also numerous issues that I addressed above, in your hyena - additional forms not wrapping around the core of the body as well, and the overuse of contour lines. The legs are handled well, although I'm not sure why you filled the back ones with hatching.

Lastly, because the alligator is so vastly different in structure, especially in its head, from the other animals we've tackled, I think you ended up getting a little bit overwhelmed. In being overwhelmed, you ended up spending more time trying to figure out the construction of it, but not necessarily in observing your reference. As a result, your drawing ended up featuring some definite simplification that is not present in your reference image. Even though construction gives us an amount of freedom to build things out logically, we still need to study our reference closely and constantly to identify which next form we can incorporate. We aren't necessarily bound to the specific recipes covered in the lesson (and to that point, that tiny box you placed on top of the head, around where the eyes were, was an interesting touch), but we still have to make sure the forms we draw accurately reflect what is actually present - not what we remember seeing.

Anyway, I've laid out a number of things for you to work on in terms of your more traditional animal drawings, and so I'm going to assign some additional drawings for you to demonstrate your understanding. I do think that overall you're moving in the right direction, but you do need to ease up on those contour lines and put more focus into how you wrap forms around one another in a believable fashion.

Next Steps:

I'd like you to submit 4 more animal drawings - stick to the more traditional quadruped stuff (no gators). I also want you to adhere to the restriction that you are not allowed to include any contour lines that sit along the surface of a single form. Only the contour lines that define the relationship between two forms are allowed - and encouraged.

When finished, reply to this critique with your revisions.
4:32 PM, Saturday August 29th 2020

Hey Uncomfortable,

Great feedback! Below are the links to the additional 4 animals with feedback taken into account.

Additional drawings: https://imgur.com/gallery/l88qgWJ

References for additional drawing: https://imgur.com/gallery/3uStXdw

7:57 PM, Saturday August 29th 2020

You've certainly made progress here, although what jumps out at me most is that you came back with your revisions rather quickly, within a couple days. Not to say you couldn't have put in loads of effort into each individual drawing, and I'm certain you have - but there is something to be said about the unwitting tendency to go through things perhaps a little more quickly when you know you're going to be doing more than one drawing in a given sitting. Also, when you receive feedback, there can be an innate desire to jump right back into the fray to correct those things, to the point that we don't necessarily reflect enough on the feedback we'd received enough before starting.

Now, I don't see any major signs of rushing, but that's just a general human behaviour and tendency to be aware of.

Looking over your work, as I mentioned you've definitely shown progress on the areas I mentioned. I did however notice certain tendencies, and they were most visible in the elephant drawing. So, I went ahead and marked them out here. As this is just a revision, I won't be going through each point as I did previously in the interest of time, so you'll have to take some care in parsing out the various notes.

One thing I do want to draw special attention to however is the tendency to add those additional forms as individual, lonely elements, that do a better job of wrapping around the underlying structure, but still tend to feel something like separate islands rather than integrating more with one another. Alternatively, you can see in the puma demo for instance, how those additional forms can instead be added in greater quantity, integrated with one another, to flesh out the musculature of the entire body. It's not that you have to cover everything, but in circumstances where they do feel like they're standing out, studying your reference more closely to find other areas where bulk may be merited can definitely help.

You can also see something similar with the dog leg demo here, how there's a lot of different forms being wrapped around the structure, not just a few key spots.

You are definitely moving in the right direction but I would like to see just a little bit more, with these points kept in mind. Please do two additional animal drawings, and stick to just one such drawing per day (rather than doing them both in the same sitting).

Next Steps:

2 additional animal drawings, with the same restrictions as before.

When finished, reply to this critique with your revisions.
5:00 PM, Tuesday September 1st 2020

Hi Uncomfortable,

Thanks for the feedback.

Addressing your comments on the elephant trunk and tusks, my construction of those parts was based on how we did stems for plants from Lesson 3, they weren't intended to be contours. If that is the incorrect way to think about constructing those please let me know.

Here are my two latest animal constructions that attempted to address all of the feedback you have provided.

Drawings: https://imgur.com/gallery/lsLLoWo

References: https://imgur.com/gallery/XoiE7y7

View more comments in this thread
The recommendation below is an advertisement. Most of the links here are part of Amazon's affiliate program (unless otherwise stated), which helps support this website. It's also more than that - it's a hand-picked recommendation of something I've used myself. If you're interested, here is a full list.
The Art of Brom

The Art of Brom

Here we're getting into the subjective - Gerald Brom is one of my favourite artists (and a pretty fantastic novelist!). That said, if I recommended art books just for the beautiful images contained therein, my list of recommendations would be miles long.

The reason this book is close to my heart is because of its introduction, where Brom goes explains in detail just how he went from being an army brat to one of the most highly respected dark fantasy artists in the world today. I believe that one's work is flavoured by their life's experiences, and discovering the roots from which other artists hail can help give one perspective on their own beginnings, and perhaps their eventual destination as well.

This website uses cookies. You can read more about what we do with them, read our privacy policy.