joxmarf

welcome! don’t redo, as that would be grinding, just add them to your warmup pool and move on :)

of course! happy to help :D

Hello, I'm Joxmarf and I will be reviewing your lesson.

First, huge congrats! The box challenge requires discipline, patience and consistency. Its repetitive nature can make it a bit of a drag, so good job for pushing through (Also, random but loved the happy face on the 222 box).

General Observations

Your lines mostly converge. You were clearly mindful of avoiding parallel or divergent lines. It still happened sometimes, of course, but I could really see the improvement as the challenge went on. Regarding the line extensions, they are done on the right direction, going away from the central point of the Y. You forgot to do the extensions for some of the boxes. Remember this is an important part of the exercise, so when you do it again for warmups do not skip it.

I would say that you didn't vary your boxes as much as you could have. The orientation of your boxes does vary, but you didn't experiment much with the length of the Y line. In your warmups, you could do boxes with the shape of cubes, bricks, rods, books, etc. Experiment!

Regarding your hatching, they are good, but remember to ghost before making a line on the page, thinking of where the line starts and where it ends. Many of you hatching lines don't reach the other side of the plane.

In some lines, you seem to have given it a second pass. I don't know if it was to hide some wobbliness or to add lineweight. If it's for the former, best to avoid it.

Overall, a very solid submission.

Good luck with the rest!

Hello, I'm Joxmarf and I will be reviewing your lesson.

First, huge congrats! The box challenge requires discipline, patience and consistency. Its repetitive nature can make it a bit of a drag, so good job for pushing through :D.

**General Observations

Your lines mostly converge. You were clearly mindful of avoiding parallel or divergent lines. Regarding the line extensions, they are done on the right direction, going away from the central point of the Y. I would say that you didn't vary your boxes as much as you could have. The orientation of your boxes are similar through the entire exercise. Remember you can play with the length of the Y lines, as well as experiment with the angles (as long as they are always over 90 degrees). In your warmups, you could do boxes with the shape of cubes, bricks, rods, books, etc. Experiment!

Regarding your hatching, they are good, but remember to ghost before making a line on the page, thinking of where the line starts and where it ends. Many of you hatching lines cross the plane. Also, in many of your boxes you retraced your lines several times with what seems to be a blue pen. Avoid this. If they were meant to add lineweight, remember to do the superimposed line with ghosting, always prioritising confidence over accuracy.

Lastly, I recommend giving each box its own space. Many of your boxes are overlapping.

Good luck with the rest!

Hello! I'm Joxmarf and I will be reviewing your Lesson 1

Superimposed Lines

There's some fraying. Remember to place your pen mindfully before doing the stroke.

Ghosted Lines

These are good. Some of your lines arc a bit. If you arer drawing from your shoulder, you could intentionally try to arc your stroke a bit in the opposite direction to counteract the natural curve.

Ghosted Planes and Ellipses

Some of your ellipses were only drawn through once. Your ellipses seem confidently drawn.

Table of Ellipses

Your ellipses are tight, but many of them aren't touching each other. Remember that you must avoid to keep them 'floating'.

Funnels

It is difficult, but remember to do your best to align them to the minor axis.

Plotted Perspective

Well done.

Rough Perspective

Well done.

Rotated boxes

You missed some boxes. Remember that, while the boxes in the corners are challenging, they are important and fear of 'ruining' the page will hold you back. Complete the exercise before moving onto the 250 challenge.

Organic Perspective

Well done. Your boxes have a shallow foreshortening, which helps keep the sense of scale consistent.

Hello! I'm Joxmarf and I will be reviewing your Lesson 1 :)

Superimposed Lines

I notice that many of your lines have fraying. Drawabox encourages to think of every mark we put on the page. That begins with thinking where to place the pen. Also, some of your lines wobble. Remember to, when you start executing the stroke, focus only on the end point and draw confidently enough not to allow your brain to steer the stroke.

Ghosted Lines

Once again, your marks wobble. Remember not to focus on accuracy, but on the confidence of your marks. Time and practice will make your lines more accurate. Also, once again, some of your lines arc. Some of your marks wobble. Remember not to focus on accuracy, but on the confidence of your marks. Time and practice will make your lines more accurate, but remember that in this course you should prioritise accuracy. Also, remember to consider from which pivot you are drawing from. We should be drawing from the shoulder.

Ghosted Planes

Many of your lines wobble. Remember to ghost and draw from your shoulder.

Table of Ellipses

I see you are drawing through your ellipses two full times, which is great. However, many of them are not evenly shaped. There could be many reasons for this. Remember to ghost mindfully and thoroughly before making the mark with confidence. Overall, these are well done.

Ellipses in Planes

Your ellipses are drawn with confidence and most of them are touching all the 4 edges of the plane. It seems that you are drawing through your ellipse more than two full times. Try to stick to only 2-3 times.

Funnels

It is quite difficult, but I would like to note that some of your ellipses are not aligned to the central minor axis line. Also, some ellipses are not touching each other. It seems that you are drawing through your ellipses more than two full times. Try to stick only to 2-3 times. Also, wobbling is still present.

Plotted Perspective

Well done.

Rough Perspective

Remember to always keep ghosting in mind. Good job, you are working with one vanishing point, as the exercise states.

Rotated boxes

Well done.

Organic Perspective

Well done.

Overall, the common issue in all of the exercises is the wobbling. I recommend to reread the section in Lesson 1 in which Uncomfortable explains the ghosting method.

Hello! I'm Joxmarf and I will be reviewing your Lesson 1 :)

Superimposed Lines

I notice that many of your lines have fraying. Drawabox encourages to think of every mark we put on the page. That begins with thinking where to place the pen. Also, some of your lines arc. Remember to, when you start executing the stroke, focus only on the end point and draw confidently enough not to allow your brain to steer the stroke.

Ghosted Lines

Some of your marks wobble. Remember not to focus on accuracy, but on the confidence of your marks. Time and practice will make your lines more accurate. Also, once again, some of your lines arc. Some of your marks wobble. Remember not to focus on accuracy, but on the confidence of your marks. Time and practice will make your lines more accurate. Also, once again, some of your lines arc. Remember to consider from which pivot you are drawing from. If you are engaging your whole arm from the shoulder, you could try to intentionally arc your stroke a litle in the opposite direction to counteract the natural curve.

Ghosted Planes

These are good! Well done.

Table of Ellipses

I see you are drawing through your ellipses two full times, which is great. However, many of them are not evenly shaped. There could be many reasons for this. Remember to ghost mindfully and thoroughly before making the mark with confidence. Overall, these are well done.

Ellipses in Planes

Good job! Your ellipses are drawn with confidence and most of them are touching all the 4 edges of the plane.

Funnels

It is quite difficult, but I would like to note that some of your ellipses are not aligned to the central minor axis line. Also, some ellipses are not touching each other.

Plotted Perspective

Awesome.

Rough Perspective

You are missing a very important part of the exercise: line extensions. Do not move to the box challenge before doing these. Also, remember to always keep ghosting in mind.

Rotated boxes

Well done.

Organic Perspective

Well done. I notice some of the lines of your boxes aren't meeting.

hello! omg thank you so much for your review :)) there's a lot of helpful advice i will keep in mind when i redo these exercises as warmups ! have a good day

thank you so much for taking the time to review my lesson! i will keep your advice in mind